When did this happen? Before one of the hurricanes forecasted to hit Houston like Rita? This is what I recall.
No, Katrina hit New Orleans in 2005 (just moved to the Houston area). A few weeks later Rita was headed directly towards Houston, but then shifted to Beaumont-Port Arthur.
Pretty sure List eater is fourth from the right. The statue creator captured the moment of her chomping down on the list, that's why she is not singing.