FW is probably correct, but Kingman should think about it harder than Shugart. Another season showing fewer brain farts on a team that should make it to Omaha would probably move Kingman up to at least the middle single-digit rounds. Shugart has to lose his headcase reputation in order to move up. If he decides he is who he is he should go.
The unfortunate part is both teams are class teams which makes the decision harder.