Actually, this strangly could potentially be a year the Big 12 title game is helpful. I am against the dumb rematch as history already has shown that rematches hurt the Big 12 more than they help.
That said, because things tend to work out that way, the stars could actually align for a positive Big 12 title the first year.
How? TCU and OU both lost to Iowa State. If Iowa State wins out and OU wins out or TCU wins out and West Virginia loses a game, we would have a TCU or OU versus Iowa State Big 12 championship game.
This is the rare scenario where the two potential #1 in the standings teams/playoff teams could actually face the team they lost to for a chance to redeem themselves.
This only happened twice during the first iteration of the championship game, however the first time it did not matter and the second time it hurt the Big 12.
In 1999, Nebraska beat Texas in the rematch after having lost to Texas in the regular season. The rematch win did nothing for Nebraska’s national title hopes. Nebraska was already #3 and would have been in the top 4 for a playoff (if one existed) before the rematch. The rematch win did not cause Nebraska to jump undefeated Florida State or undefeated Virginia Tech and get into the BCS title game.
In 2007, Missouri lost to OU the first time. Missouri ended up in a rematch against OU the second time. Missouri, however, did not need redemption as it was ranked #1 going into the Big 12 title game. Losing to OU again and falling to #7 not only would have knocked Missouri out of playoff if one existed, but it did knock Missouri out of the BCS bowls completely (and Kansas, who Missouri beat, ended up going to the Orange Bowl and winning it).
In 2000, 2001, 2002, and 2005, the better team faced a rematch against a team they already beat that could only hurt them and would not help them in any way.
I would like to state I would ideally like to see a TCU-Iowa State rematch with a TCU win just to see if it actually helps TCU or not. If TCU gets in over other 1 loss teams in a contested ranking and was not ranked in the top 4 before the championship game, it could be argued the Big 12 championship actually helped. If TCU does not get in after beating Iowa State, it would prove the game is meaningless and what is holding TCU back is their jerseys do not say “Oklahoma.”
-
Like x 1
Last edited: Nov 10, 2017