Can a second grader know he's transgender?

Discussion in 'West Mall' started by Macanudo, Feb 13, 2008.

  1. Macanudo

    Macanudo 2,500+ Posts

  2. naijahorn

    naijahorn 250+ Posts

  3. PipFunatUT

    PipFunatUT 500+ Posts

    doubt it, but he has every right in the world to think he does....
     
  4. SubliminalHorn

    SubliminalHorn 500+ Posts

    I believe so
     
  5. drycreek

    drycreek Guest

    I would say so. I'm not completely sure though. I guess it would be no different than a boy who gay and has always known he was gay.
     
  6. bobtheking

    bobtheking 100+ Posts

    This could be a phase too... See tomboys, why aren't they transgender?

    edit : nvm after reading the article that was kind of a stupid question
     
  7. TahoeHorn

    TahoeHorn 1,000+ Posts

    One girl was called Jean Marie
    Another little girl was called Felicity
    Another little girl was Sally Joy
    The other was me, and I'm a boy

    My name is Bill and I'm a headcase
    They practice making up on my face
    Yeah, I feel lucky if I get trousers to wear
    Spend ages taking hairpins from my hair

    Chorus 1
    I'm a boy, I'm a boy
    But my ma won't admit it
    I'm a boy, I'm a boy
    But if I say I am I get it

    Put your frock on Jean Marie
    Plait your hair Felicity
    Paint your nails, little Sally Joy
    Put this wig on, little boy

    Chorus 1

    I wanna play cricket on the green
    Ride my bike across the street
    Cut myself and see my blood
    I wanna come home all covered in mud

    Chorus 2
    I'm a boy, I'm a boy
    But my ma won't admit it
    I'm a boy, I'm a boy, I'm a boy
    I'm a boy, I'm a boy, I'm a boy, I'm a boy
    I'm a boy, I'm a boy, I'm__ a__ boy__

    ------------------------

    The little fella in the article needs to trade places with "Bill".
     
  8. Summerof79

    Summerof79 2,500+ Posts

    Yes-

    If you have been around children enough you realize that by about 2nd grade the differences become more visible. Now my girls didn't know what it was but they liked the kid and called him a "boy-girl" when I was trying to help her buy a birthday present.
     
  9. SubliminalHorn

    SubliminalHorn 500+ Posts

    Kudos to the school for how they're handling the situation
     
  10. TahoeHorn

    TahoeHorn 1,000+ Posts

    I certainly think the school system should handle this thing sympathetically. But I'm uneasy about solutions which are very costly. I wouldn't be inclined to provide mental health professionals or separate bathrooms and such.

    I went to school in rural Alabama in the Sixties. We had some kids who were metally retarded. They were treated very nicely even by other kids except when they picked fights which wasn't too often. Introducing a lot of rules, formality and an aura that somebody in high places is micromanaging the daily supervision process of teachers is a bad thing. If he/she's in Miss McGillicuddy's second grade class and she's a good person, I say give her a few hours training, give her the ball and keep everybody out of her hair.
     

Share This Page