Devloping Logjam at QB

Discussion in 'On The Field' started by ViperHorn, Dec 5, 2018.

  1. ViperHorn

    ViperHorn 5,000+ Posts

    Currently, 4 QB's all with playing time remaining - Sam 2 years, Shane 1 year, Rising 4 years and Thompson 4 years. For 2019 Johnson will initially be the QB recruit with Card for 2020. Something has to give after the Sugar Bowl with Shane, Rising, and Thompson. Was the lack of playing time for Shane when Sam was hurt due to an agreement with him to Red Shirt so he can transfer with eligibility? Thompson ran the scout team this season which implies that Rising is the solid number 3 (and would move up to 2 if Shane leaves). Odd man out after the Sugar Bowl at QB seems to be Thompson, but could he play another position?

    Joe Fan what does it look like to you?
     
    • Like Like x 2
  2. Buck-Horn

    Buck-Horn 500+ Posts

    I think Shane is gone & agree Thompson could move to a new position. The most interesting facet of this QB “problem” (which is a good one!) is Johnson. Is he a JT Barrett? If so, Hernan will have a very tough delimma on his hands. While Sam has dramatically improved over the season, he is not elite yet. If Johnson gives us a VY-type skill set, he SHOULD be our guy....at least by 2020. I’ll let Joe give us his wisdom.....
     
    • Like Like x 1
  3. easy

    easy 2,500+ Posts

    Herman had the same issue at Ohio state and it worked itself out, it will do the same here
     
    • Agree Agree x 2
    • Like Like x 1
  4. Buck-Horn

    Buck-Horn 500+ Posts

    Good point!!:hookem:
     
  5. Ajo Macho

    Ajo Macho 100+ Posts

    Shane still has two years of eligibility, since he can take a redshirt for this year.
     
    • Agree Agree x 2
  6. ViperHorn

    ViperHorn 5,000+ Posts

    I don't think he had 4 with 2 experienced and 2 true freshmen without experience. All I can remember is 3 and one of those was a senior. However it is not a question of Herman working it out - it is a question of how to keep 5+ QB's involved in the team without losing any to another program.
     
    • Agree Agree x 2
  7. BabHorn

    BabHorn 10,000+ Posts

    Nice problem to have. I also think Shane is transferring but could be wrong. Whatever Shane decides to do, and it wouldn't surprise me if he decided to stay, Texas is getting into a situation now where QBs coming in can expect to sit at least two years unless they are transcendent talents.
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  8. Clean

    Clean 5,000+ Posts

    As long as they don't transfer to blowU like Mayfield and Murray, I'm good with Shane et al. going elsewhere.

    I was glad to see ex-Clemson QB Kelly Bryant transferred to Mizzou. He was rumored to be heading to the mobile home state's top university too.
     
  9. WorsterMan

    WorsterMan 10,000+ Posts

    I'm confident, IF Boo were to be released to transfer, there will be some established boundaries where he can go. He differently will not be allowed to transfer to ou and PERHAPS no programs in the Big 12 that the Horns compete with.

    His sisters attend(ed) ou and I suspect as much as he wanted to go to UT, he would not want to transfer to ou anyway....
     
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2018
  10. #2is#1

    #2is#1 1,000+ Posts

    Carolina?
    I think he would be released immediately.
     
  11. #2is#1

    #2is#1 1,000+ Posts

    IMO Shane should go.
    He seems to not quite fit the offense.
    He is a great kid, teammate, and leader.
    But, for whatever reason not the apple of TH’s eye.
    Much respect for him as a player. But he should go. I would suggest Carolina.
    But IMHO he should transfer.
     
  12. slowrider

    slowrider 100+ Posts

    Don’t think you have all the facts on this one. Josh Heuple recruited Shane pretty hard and then when he got fired and Lincoln arrived OU went in a different direction. OU signed Austin Kendall as their 2016 QB.

    His big brother Garret played baseball at OU and was all Big 12. His sisters also went to OU. I believe he would have been a Sooner if Josh Heuple didn’t get the boot. He just wasn’t a fit for Lincoln’s system then or now.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  13. ProdigalHorn

    ProdigalHorn 10,000+ Posts

    Herman let Bonney go to Tech, so I wouldn't put that in stone.

    I do think that in the long run it probably is better for him to transfer with his two years, but if he stays, he's certainly welcome - although far from guaranteed a spot from what I'm hearing about Rising.
     
    Last edited: Dec 7, 2018
  14. I_Dont_Exist

    I_Dont_Exist 1,000+ Posts

    Sam isn't likely to leave early for the NFL. I can't see Rising waiting patiently for 2 more years.
     
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2018
  15. Ajo Macho

    Ajo Macho 100+ Posts

    I don't know much about Rising on a personal level, but I could see almost any QB sticking around if they have the idea they'll be the starting QB for two years on a playoff contender.

    If we keep improving next year, it'll go a long way towards preventing transfers and early NFL draftees. If we don't, back to the past 9 years of lacking senior talent.
     
  16. Austin_Bill

    Austin_Bill 500+ Posts

    I have a few thoughts on the subject.

    1. Shane (can't call him Boo, it's just weird) is going to transfer, there is no other reason that he redshirted this year. Where? I have no idea, but blOwU has a pretty good log jam of QBs as well. My guess is a place like Arkansas or out west. I wish him the best.

    2. I'm pretty sure Sam is a 4 year starter for Texas, but he is also injury prone and I highly doubt he will ever finish a season without an injury.

    3. I think one of Rising or Thompson will transfer, it only makes sense that one will win the 2nd string job and the other will likely move on. I think it likely won't happen next season but the following one.

    4. Roshon is going to come in and redshirt and then he will compete with likely fall into place as the 3rd string for one year. In 2021 he will compete for a starting spot with the winner of Rising/Thompson.

    5. Card is coming in in 2020 and will redshirt and take his place as 3rd string in 2021 and he will compete for a starting spot in 2022.

    I can't believe I am looking at what is going to happen in 2022. I honestly hope we keep Beck for a very long time, he is a really good QB coach.
     
  17. zuckercanyon

    zuckercanyon 500+ Posts

    Boo should immediately transfer to North Carolina where Mack can coddle him and remind him daily he’s a good kid.
     
    • poop poop x 5
    • Dislike Dislike x 2
    • Funny Funny x 1
  18. Austin_Bill

    Austin_Bill 500+ Posts

    You remind me of the little kid in the Movie "A League of their own". I would say you are drunk, but you are a simple minded individual.
     
    • Like Like x 2
    • Agree Agree x 1
    • Winner Winner x 1
  19. slowrider

    slowrider 100+ Posts

    I wonder if Rising is second guessing his decision to flip to UT now that he is firmly entrenched behind a two year starter. If he would have stayed with his commitment to OU he would be competing for the starting position. I realize there is a relationship with Herman and his father but he would be running an offense that just produced back to back Heisman winners.
     
  20. 2003TexasGrad

    2003TexasGrad 1,000+ Posts

    I'm glad this is what we are discussing/debating in December and not that we dont have any good QBs.
     
    • Agree Agree x 6
    • Like Like x 2
  21. moondog_LFZ

    moondog_LFZ 1,000+ Posts

    Sam is improved but not all world.
    And he is injury prone.
    Rising is just as big or bigger than Sam and has a better arm.
    All it takes is Sam missing a couple of games and Rising could entrench himself.
    No position on this team should be considered safe.
     
    • Agree Agree x 12
  22. slowrider

    slowrider 100+ Posts

    So Cam Rising is now in the transfer portal? This kid is a flake. Flipped to UT a couple of weeks before signing day after he was committed for over a year to OU and now he is transferring after a redshirt year.
     
  23. slowrider

    slowrider 100+ Posts

    And now rumors that Casey Thompson is transferring as well? What’s going on in the QB room?

    Logjam has officially been cleared.
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • Agree Agree x 1
    • Hot Hot x 1
  24. easy

    easy 2,500+ Posts

    Shot in the dark here but I’m assuming Shane made up his mind to stay and be a backup so rising will stay number 3 and didn’t like it. He will be a redshirt freshman next year Still has 4 years in Austin a lot can happen in that time. If he leaves wish him the best, but I at least would have stuck around until the end of my sophomore year.
     
    • Like Like x 1
    Last edited: Dec 22, 2018
  25. Vol Horn 4 Life

    Vol Horn 4 Life 5,000+ Posts

    This is the reason we should recruit two of the very best QBs every year. These days the elite one's think they will come in, take over the starting job, win a championship and a heisman. Some will stick and develop while some will transfer when that doesn't happen. I believe that is just the youth of today and specifically the QB position because it's not easy to spread playing time around like others.
     
  26. moondog_LFZ

    moondog_LFZ 1,000+ Posts

    Where can I find this "portal"?
    I find one tweet on Reddit saying basically the same as you.
    No link or substantiation.
    Prove it I say. ;)
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  27. easy

    easy 2,500+ Posts

     
    • Dislike Dislike x 1
  28. slowrider

    slowrider 100+ Posts

  29. moondog_LFZ

    moondog_LFZ 1,000+ Posts

  30. dukesteer

    dukesteer 2,500+ Posts

    Personally I believe that Rising would be making a huge mistake. I love Boo but he’s not the backup answer. Rising or Thompson are. Prove it in the spring and you’re one play away from being the starter.

    Had the backup played stellar when called on this season, he would have solidified the perception that there would be a competition for the starting position for 2019. Boo was adequate, that’s all. We need better.

    Rising needs to step back and reassess. If he’s good enough to start somewhere else, he needs to be a big boy and win the job here.

    Geez, the kid hasn’t played one down in college and he’s in line to be the starter here for at least two years if he’s good enough.
     
    • Agree Agree x 2
    • Winner Winner x 1
    Last edited: Dec 22, 2018

Share This Page