Did Amber Guyger kill Botham Shem Jean over noise? A friend of mine knew the man who was shot, and knew him to be an upstanding, godly man who was deeply involved with the church. At least according to the family's attorney, witnesses completely refute the officer's testimony of events, most of which didn't pass the smell test at first reading. It seems the only people who don't think the cop broke in and killed this man are in the Dallas PD - which now claims to have found pot in his apartment. Lawyers "disgusted" by release of search warrant showing marijuana found in Botham Jean's apartment So far the leading theories are romance-gone-bad, drunken rage over loud noise from upstairs, or utter and completely stupidity/incompetence. Regardless, if DPD actually gets this woman off, it's going to get ugly. This is clearly someone who has no business being a cop.