Vince decided to skip his senior year. Oh well. Tebow simply played more, so he was able to rack up more accolades, wins etc... Anyone who watches VY highlights next to Tebow highlights would be lying if they actually picked Tebown over VY.
Tebow scored 57 rushing TDs vs. 37 for VY. Here is where they scored them from: VY scored 24 of his TDs from beyond the 5-yard line. Tebow scored only 16.
I would take Vince over Tebow in college on any field, any day, any time. Jesus part deux can come in second...
VY is the better player. TT had the better career. They each had a single season that was pretty phenomenal. I don't think that the nod to Tebow is a stretch.