Haven't made it there yet, but reviews from friends say its very good. They know what they are doing. As far as what to choose I cant say aince I havent been, but a prime ribeye steak is always fantastic if prepared correctly......mooing with a little salt and pepper.
I did end up going. I wasn't that impressed. The room we were in was very crowded and loud with small children. The beer selection was "meh". The appetizers were good. My steak had a very pungent odor to it, somewhat like the hocks of a rutting buck smells like. It was not appetizing. The mashed potatoes were great, but I was not overwhelmed by the food. I wouldn't suggest it to anyone else if they were looking for a really nice place to go.